Ever wondered why some websites lose 80% of their traffic after migration while others sail through without a scratch? I've seen this scenario play out too many times in my many years of SEO consulting. The difference between success and failure often comes down to one thing: a comprehensive website migration SEO checklist.
Whether you're changing domains, redesigning your site, or switching to a new CMS, a proper migration strategy is non-negotiable if you want to preserve your hard-earned search rankings. In this guide, I'll walk you through every critical step to ensure your next website transition maintains (or even improves) your SEO performance.
A website migration is any significant change to a website that can impact search engine visibility – including domain changes, redesigns, URL restructuring, content overhauls, or platform migrations. Without proper planning, these changes can lead to devastating traffic losses and ranking drops that may take months or years to recover from.
I've guided hundreds of businesses through successful migrations, and I've developed this checklist based on real-world experiences and data-driven insights. Following these steps will help you maintain your SEO equity and avoid the pitfalls that cause most migrations to fail.
Understanding the type of migration you're undertaking is crucial, as each presents unique challenges and requires specific approaches:
| Migration Type | Description | SEO Risk Level | Key Considerations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Domain Change | Moving from one domain to another (e.g., .com to .co.uk) | High | Brand recognition, backlinks transfer, domain authority |
| Platform/CMS Migration | Switching content management systems | Medium-High | URL structure, template changes, schema implementation |
| Website Redesign | Major visual and structural changes | Medium | Content preservation, internal linking, UX signals |
| URL Structure Change | Reorganizing URL patterns site-wide | Medium-High | Redirect mapping, internal links, sitemap updates |
| HTTP to HTTPS | Securing the website with SSL | Low-Medium | Certificate implementation, mixed content issues |
| Mobile Migration | Implementing responsive design or mobile version | Medium | Mobile usability, page speed, mobile-first indexing |
Many migrations involve multiple types simultaneously, which compounds both risk and complexity. For example, a company might change domains while also implementing a new CMS and redesign – a "triple threat" migration that requires exceptionally careful planning.
Preparation is everything when it comes to website migration. I always tell my clients that 80% of migration success happens before a single line of code is changed.
First, define what success looks like:
Before migrating, thoroughly document your current website's status:
I recommend using tools like Semrush, Ahrefs, or Screaming Frog for comprehensive auditing.
Ensure all teams understand the SEO requirements:
Create a realistic migration schedule that includes:
The technical foundation of your migration will determine how search engines interpret and index your new site.
Content is the cornerstone of your SEO value. Preserving and enhancing it during a website migration is essential.
Create a comprehensive content inventory that includes:
| Content Element | Migration Action | Priority Level |
|---|---|---|
| Top organic landing pages | Preserve with minimal changes | Critical |
| High-converting pages | Preserve with A/B testing for improvements | Critical |
| Core service/product pages | Preserve with enhancements | High |
| Blog content | Migrate with URL preservation | Medium-High |
| Support/FAQ content | Update and enhance | Medium |
| Low-value/outdated content | Consider consolidating or removing | Low |
Take advantage of the migration to enhance content where appropriate:
Before launch, thoroughly test migrated content:
Redirects are the critical bridges between your old and new sites. Poor redirect implementation is the #1 cause of traffic loss during website migration.
Document every URL that needs redirection:
Plan for these common redirection challenges:
| Situation | Recommended Approach |
|---|---|
| Content no longer exists | Redirect to most relevant alternative or category page |
| Multiple old pages consolidated | Redirect all to new consolidated page |
| Content split into multiple pages | Redirect to most topically relevant new page |
| Parameter-based URLs | Create pattern matching rules |
| Non-HTML resources (PDFs, etc.) | Redirect to new version or equivalent content |
The day of migration requires careful orchestration and monitoring to catch issues early.
The weeks following your website migration are critical for identifying and resolving issues before they impact rankings.
Based on hundreds of migrations I've managed, these are the most frequent problems and their solutions:
| Common Issue | Symptoms | Solution |
|---|---|---|
| Missing Redirects | Spike in 404 errors, traffic drops to specific sections | Identify missing redirects in logs and implement immediately |
| Robots.txt Blocking | Sudden drop in indexed pages | Check and correct robots.txt directives |
| Canonical Tag Issues | Duplicate content warnings, indexation problems | Audit and correct canonical implementation |
| Internal Link Breakage | High bounce rates, poor user flow | Run crawl to identify and fix broken internal links |
| Slow Page Loading | Increased bounce rate, reduced crawl frequency | Optimize server response time, compress resources |
| Mobile Usability Issues | Mobile traffic drops, poor engagement metrics | Address mobile usability issues flagged in Search Console |
| Content Quality Loss | Ranking drops for specific terms | Compare old/new content versions and restore lost value |
Client: UK-based home furnishings retailer with 50,000+ products
Migration Type: Platform migration from Magento 1 to Shopify Plus with URL restructuring
Challenge: Migration needed to be completed within a tight two-month window while preserving rankings for 30,000+ organic landing pages.
Approach:
Results:
Client: SaaS company expanding from UK to global markets
Migration Type: Domain change from .co.uk to .com with multilingual implementation
Challenge: Preserving UK rankings while establishing international visibility and implementing hreflang for 5 languages.
Approach:
Results:
Here are some essential resources to help you plan and execute your website migration:
A successful website migration requires meticulous planning, thorough execution, and vigilant monitoring. By following this comprehensive checklist, you'll significantly reduce the risk of traffic and ranking losses that typically plague migrations.
Remember that some fluctuation is normal – even with perfect implementation, expect a temporary dip of 10-15% in traffic that should recover within 4-8 weeks as search engines process your changes. The key is minimizing this impact through careful preparation and quickly addressing any issues that arise.
If you're planning a complex migration or don't have the in-house expertise to manage the process, I strongly recommend working with experienced SEO professionals. The cost of professional migration support is invariably less than the potential revenue loss from a failed migration.
Need personalized guidance for your website migration? Contact me for a consultation, and I'll help ensure your transition maintains or improves your hard-earned search visibility.
This article was written by Gaz Hall, a UK based SEO Consultant on 10th December 2024. Gaz has over 25 years experience working on SEO projects large and small, locally and globally across a range of sectors. If you need any SEO advice or would like me to look at your next project then get in touch to arrange a free consultation.
© Copyright 2025 Search Auth Ltd (Company Number 12683577)